Shutting out the noise: Voltage references for precision analog signal paths in space applicationsStory
October 08, 2014
When designers are trying to select a component in the signal path of a satellite system, it is often difficult to find a device with both the radiation tolerance and accuracy required. Signal integrity is, after all, the key specification when designing an analog signal chain. The main causes of error to the integrity of the signal chain can be divided into two categories: inaccuracies due to noise and inaccuracies due to shifts in voltage. While it is important to consider all components in the signal path, one component is the most critical in achieving precision performance: the voltage reference.
Noise in a system can be reduced with the correct use of filters and the averaging of measurements when converting a signal from the analog domain to the digital domain. However, large or complex filters require board space and increased component count, not to mention added weight, which results in higher costs. Large filters also increase the settling time for transient response. Averaging saves on extra component cost but comes at the expense of sample frequency. The A/D converter requires a voltage reference with lower noise than the signal being measured to take advantage of averaging. For example, a 20-bit system requires the voltage reference to have a noise of less than 1 part per million (ppm). If the system requires higher precision than a voltage reference can deliver, averaging can still be used but will be extremely costly, as multiple analog-to-digital converters are needed. Each converter has its own voltage reference and the measurement from each is then averaged.
In the last five years, several manufacturers have offered references with noise in the single-ppm peak-to-peak levels. For traditional bandgap references, about 600 mV of Proportional To Absolute Temperature (PTAT) voltage is generated and added to a single-transistor base-to-emitter voltage (Vbe) to produce the basic bandgap voltage of ~1.22 V. An output amplifier (which may be part of the bandgap itself) gains and buffers the internal bandgap voltage up to a standard output. The 600 mV of PTAT has been created from a single delta-Vbe (ΔVbe) structure made from two transistors running at different current densities generating a voltage ΔVbe=(KT/q)*In(R) where K is Boltzmann’s constant, T is absolute temperature, q is the electric charge, and R is the current density ratio between the two transistors. A common design has R=8 and ΔVbe=54 mV. To bring this up to 600 mV will require a gain of about 11. That gain of 11 will amplify device noises and instabilities directly.
One solution to reduce the noise in a bandgap reference is to employ cascaded ΔVbe rather than an amplified ΔVbe. That is to say, the design effectively adds 11 of those R=8 units in sequence to generate the 600 mV. This has profound effects on the noise. If one adds the noise of 11 identical units, the result is only √11 noise amplification or a 3.3-fold improvement. It is better than that, though, because the mechanisms that give the gain of 11 in a standard bandgap more than double the ΔVbe noise. Figure 1 shows the peak-to-peak noise of a bandgap reference with the cascaded ΔVbe topology.
When a voltage reference is exposed to radiation, the noise increases. Although the increase in noise is not large, the above solution keeps the increase even lower. Also, popcorn noise sources would only exist sparsely with perhaps one site on a die, and they would not receive the gain of 11. If popcorn noise is in fact found, it will be an order of magnitude smaller than in a traditional bandgap reference.
Figure 1: ISL71090 voltage reference peak-to-peak noise plot.
(Click graphic to zoom by 1.9x)
Lowering voltage shifts
Voltage shifts in a system may be reduced with fairly simple additional circuitry, although making adjustments across a full temperature range presents added difficulty. The cost of the additional circuitry is also high. Furthermore, offset voltages can only be corrected if they are actually detected, meaning there must be a fixed voltage accurate enough to use as a base for the rest of the system. Once again, the critical component of the system is the voltage reference, which sets the common mode for amplifiers, can be used to trigger comparators, and may be used to provide a stable supply to sensitive sensors. Most importantly, it sets the accuracy for the A/D and D/A converters.
Key aspects to consider on a voltage reference include initial accuracy, drift over temperature, drift over time, and shift over radiation. Many voltage references provide trim options to adjust initial accuracy; however, the process requires external circuitry and may adversely affect the other specifications. A much simpler approach is to calibrate out the error on the digital side. Note that digital calibration reduces the total input signal voltage range by the amount of the error. Bandgap references can be found with an initial accuracy within hundredths of a percent before radiation.
Drift over temperature in precision voltage references is caused by imperfections in the elements making up the device and is not linear. The uncompensated curve of a bandgap reference is about 20 ppm. One solution to improve the temperature coefficient of the device is to use translinear circuitry to compensate for the curve by adding an exponential term to the current summation. With curve compensation, a designer is able to achieve a temperature coefficient lower than 3 ppm.
Drift over time is independent of other shifts and occurs predominantly toward the beginning of the life of the reference. Thus, initial calibration does not help correct for this drift. Calibration after an initial burn-in period is an option, albeit at the expense of the burn-in time. Moreover, the cascade design for creating a bandgap reference does not only help reduce noise, but it also has been found to reduce the long-term drift as well. The improved drift performance is seen in Figure 2.
Figure 2: ISL71091 voltage reference long-term drift.
(Click graphic to zoom by 1.9x)
Shifts due to radiation are critical in space applications. Many voltage references provide excellent accuracy in industrial environments but have large shifts when exposed to radiation. Research has shown that low-dose-rate radiation best mimics the actual conditions in space. Low dose rate used in testing is typically 10 mrad(Si)/s. While this is a higher rate compared to the naturally occurring radiation in space, it is a compromise between the time needed to complete the radiation testing and the dose rate chosen. Testing at high dose rates (50-300 rad(Si)/s) can produce secondary effects due to the accelerated nature of the dose rate. It is highly recommended to select devices that have undergone both low-dose and high-dose-rate radiation testing on a wafer-by-wafer basis. Radiation hardening is achieved both through design and also through the process used in creating the device. A good solution for a radiation-tolerant process is to have the transistors oxide-isolated and diffused neither too shallow so as to be sensitive to radiation-damaged oxides, nor diffused so deeply as to increase layout size and lower frequency responses. Table 1 shows a comparison of key specifications over radiation of three of the top competing voltage references.
Table 1: Comparison of top voltage references for space applications.
(Click graphic to zoom by 1.9x)
Voltage references directly affect signal integrity because they are used as the standard that the signal is compared to when it is converted from the analog domain to the digital domain. Calibration and compensation methods exist, but are often expensive and may consume significant board space. New designs, testing, and wafer process techniques, like those used in Intersil’s ISL71090 and ISL71091 voltage references (shown in Figure 3), are improving specifications and minimizing or even eliminating the need for calibration.
Figure 3: ISL71091SEH voltage references ensure signal-processing integrity and improve voltage accuracy in satellite applications. (Photo courtesy of Intersil Corp.)
(Click graphic to zoom)
Dan Goodhew is an Applications Engineer for Precision Products at Intersil Corp. He specializes in precision op amps and voltage references, both commercial and radiation-hardened, along with digitally controlled potentiometers and their application in data-acquisition systems. He holds a BSEE from the University of Central Florida. Readers may reach him at [email protected].
Intersil Corp 408-432-8888 www.intersil.com