VITA 75 vs. VPX: Optimizing unmanned vehicle thermal and payload efficienciesStory
July 31, 2013
The fast pace of UAV/UGV/UUV evolution places an ever-increasing demand on size, weight, and power, while the range of use applications ? from surveillance to air defense to communications relays ? and interest from national security organizations beyond military continue to grow. To accommodate increasing requirements and diminishing budgets, public contractors and private vendors are moving to Size, Weight, Power, and Cost (SWaP-C)-savvy standards-based systems design, such as by utilizing the smaller envelopes of VITA 75 small form factors to replace existing 3U and 6U VPX technologies. This allows the integration of future payload capabilities into the space available in existing mobile platforms.
Military vehicles are getting smaller. Today’s fighting forces are increasingly equipped with vehicles that are remotely teleoperated by soldiers, and also operate semi-autonomously. These unmanned vehicles operate in the air, on ground, at sea, and underwater (UAV, UGV, USV, UUV), and are rapidly comprising an increasing percentage of the U.S. fleet. These vehicles are tools used to perform the vital military task of protecting and extending the capabilities of the modern warfighter.
The absence of troops in-vehicle does not lessen the processing demand for unmanned vehicles. High-performance computer systems with greater processing capabilities, wider and higher-speed data buses, and more and higher-resolution sensors are required to enable the autonomous functions when a vehicle is unmanned. The higher data input and processing needs demand that these smaller vehicles provide the space necessary for cooling that allows for reliable, high-performance operation.
Thermal dissipation requires space, and space in these small unmanned vehicles is a scarce commodity. The operating environment of unmanned vehicles is no less demanding than that of manned vehicles. Temperatures can be just as extreme, but in these smaller vehicles, cooling computer systems becomes even more difficult.
3U and 6U VPX embedded systems have evolved to keep up with the latest bus speeds of modern CPUs while holding SWaP at bay. These relatively compact solutions are currently fulfilling modern requirements for high-performance computing in mobile military platforms. These systems provide connectivity, as well as the wide, high-speed I/O required to support visible spectrum and infrared cameras, radar, and other fast, high-definition sensors. At the heart of these systems is the processing power (CPUs, GPGPUs, FPGAs) required to process that data for object detection, classification, and tracking.
All these functions are required in smaller unmanned platforms, but these vehicles have tighter payload restrictions than their larger brethren. Every bit of weight and volume that can be removed from a system has the potential to improve the range, capabilities, or cost of a deployed unit, so engineers must consider the function of every cubic centimeter of space, and each gram of weight. This is where Small Form Factor (SFF) VITA 75-based systems excel; all unnecessary space can be squeezed from the system to reduce its size, and unnecessary mass can be eliminated. And while dissipating the thermal energy produced by these systems does require space, making the electronics portion of a system smaller leaves more space available for that thermal dissipation.
Sidebar 1: Breaking down SWaP-C
(Click graphic to zoom)
Efficiencies and space
One part of unmanned systems design that is often overlooked is empty space (air space), or mass. In military unmanned vehicle applications, each ounce or cubic inch of space that can be removed from a computing subsystem has the potential to improve the range, capabilities, or cost of a deployed unit. To this end, again, engineers must consider the function of every bit of cubic space and each ounce of weight. All unnecessary space should be squeezed from the system to reduce its size, and any unnecessary mass should be eliminated (see Sidebar 1). If included in the system design, the purpose of air space should be well understood. For instance, systems may include empty space because the design requires a particular internal or external surface area for convective thermal dissipation. Similarly, thermal transfer or sinking might require material mass to be designed into the unmanned vehicle system.
Consider the large and heavy thermally conductive pathways that distribute heat from critical components in VPX design. This conductive scheme distributes the energy from each board in a chassis via contact with slotted card guides, thereby facilitating the flow of internal temperatures to the external skin of the enclosure. The conductive components, as a function of their mass, also have a sinking capacity within themselves. This mass adds thermal sinking capacity, and can therefore average out peaks of the thermal demand of the processing components. Physical pressure, provided by wedge locks, maximizes the contact area between the thermal shunts on the blades and the slots. While wedge locks increase the shunt-to-slot contact area opposite the wedge lock, the wedge locks themselves, which provide pressure based on interlocking wedges, present a low (<50%) contact area. Every other wedge on the device can only contact the slot or the blade, but not both (Figure 1). The resulting effect is that the use of bladed slots actually reduces potential contact area, conductivity, and the resulting thermal efficiency of VPX.
Figure 1: Physical pressure from wedge locks maximizes the contact area between thermal shunts; the wedge locks cannot contact both blades and slots, reducing conductivity and thermal efficiency in the bladed designs of VPX.
(Click graphic to zoom)
By contrast, within a VITA 75 form factor system such as the Extreme Rugged HPERC, critical components are positioned an absolute minimum distance from heat dissipating elements. This system integrates a high-efficiency heat spreader between these components and the external heat dissipater (Figure 2). The spreader is compact, to minimize ΔT and to increase thermal transfer to the outside of the system.
Figure 2: VITA 75 designs incorporate a high-efficiency, compact heat spreader to increase thermal transfer to outside the system.
(Click graphic to zoom by 1.9x)
System and component standards
Standards that define the scope of system architectures, such as VPX and VITA 75, provide uniformity and modularity at various levels of a system. These requirements put pressure on system developers, because the form factors they select can require compromises to overall SWaP design.
As previously mentioned, power or electrical efficiency is chiefly driven by the evolution of processors. However, to address thermal challenges, higher cooling efficiency has been achieved with systems based on the VITA 75 standard. An example is ADLINK’s HPERC system, which uses the highest-efficiency processors, improves thermal design, and reduces system size to improve the SWaP equation and, as a result, the unmanned system’s payload efficiency. These improvements come by removing or shrinking elements like wedge locks, thermal shunts, connectors, and carriers that purport to provide ease of configuration and repair, but are unnecessary for system performance.
Additionally, VPX specifies a robust bus scheme featuring rugged bus connector utilization and an infrastructure of bladed expansion cards. The modular bladed architecture has the ability to be easily expanded and reconfigured internally to accommodate changing requirements, but these ubiquitous components – while implementing standardization internally – add nothing to, and in fact subtract from, the performance equation. Wedge locks, for instance, are unnecessary when thermal energy is not required to traverse a sliding slot mechanism. They are a cost in size, weight, and performance.
System size and weight can be reduced significantly while improving thermal efficiency when specifications, such as VITA 75, define the box-level solution rather than define overly constrained requirements that penetrate to the interior form factor of a system. The weight of an enclosure card slot can exceed 1 lb. and, by eliminating it, the critical components can move closer to the dissipater. Some comparisons show the resultant improvement from lowered thermal resistance compared with VPX can exceed 48 percent. Clearly, the removal of thermally conductive card slots does nothing to reduce processing performance, but can shave more than 1 lb. of payload.
VITA 75: A winning solution for unmanned systems
When designing unmanned systems, the key to realizing the benefits from SFF computing systems lies in rethinking the aspects of the open standards that are required by the end user. VPX blades and card cages provide an easy way to configure mix-n-match modularity, which is convenient in the lab. But when a higher level of integration is required in-vehicle, modular design must be deconstructed. Careful VITA 75 design has removed some aspects of modularity in order to improve SWaP; as mentioned, it is a specification that defines an SFF, box-level standard, and is based heavily on the voice of the customer, focusing on both the size and the level of ruggedization of the operating environment (Figure 3). The result is a game-changing improvement in situational awareness that not only preserves unmanned vehicles themselves, but also provides the quality and volume of information needed for total control of battlefield technologies and unprecedented force protection.
Figure 3: The ADLINK HPERC is a sealed, rugged COTS computing platform incorporating VITA 75 and other industry standard technology and long-life processing architecture.
(Click graphic to zoom by 1.9x)
Mike Jones, product manager at ADLINK, focused on factory automation equipment, devising algorithms, optics, and mechanics for sensitive, high-speed material analysis in the harsh environments of aluminum, steel, and paper production after cutting his teeth on avionics in the U.S. Navy. He went on to develop personal computer products for the consumer market, creating forward-looking, now ubiquitous industrial designs. At ADLINK, he now directs and champions the advancement of ADLINK’s Extreme Rugged system products. He can be contacted at [email protected]
ADLINK Technology Inc. 408-360-4328 www.adlinktech.com